Technology

The Open Internet is Over

Confronting Reality in Cyberspace
Jul 13, 2022 By Will Hurd
Updated: Dec 27, 2023
Will Hurd Cyber Dall-e Image
3 MIN READ
The author generated this image with DALL-E, OpenAI’s transformer language model.

The technological change we have seen in the last forty years has been astonishing. Consider the Internet: In the 1980s to download a 5 MB file we had to get the approval of everyone in the house to use a 2400 Baud modem, because it would tie up the landline for 5 hours. In the 2020s, we can use artificial intelligence to generate high quality images in seconds or watch a movie on a computer we carry in our pockets – a smart phone.

When I was playing on my 23 lb. Commodore 64 computer, or taking computer science classes in high school and then majoring in computer science at Texas A&M University, one of the things that I always believed was that the Internet was going to be free and open for everyone. But this is one of the many preconceptions that a Council on Foreign Relations Independent Task Force on Cybersecurity, on which I was recently proud to serve, has had to debunk.

The Internet has become “a vital part of modern life, providing a backbone for critical civilian infrastructure, facilitating global digital trade, and promoting the exchange of ideas.”But, as we stated in our Task Force report, “The era of the global internet is over.”

“The era of the global internet is over.”

Here are our three primary conclusions:

  • The Internet is Divided – U.S. policies promoting an open, global internet have failed, and Washington will be unable to stop or reverse the trend toward fragmentation. Data is a source of geopolitical power and competition and is seen as central to economic and national security.
  • The Risks in Cyberspace are Rising – Increased digitization increases vulnerability to digital breaches, exposing every aspect of business and statecraft to disruption, theft, or manipulation. These breaches are generally used for espionage, political advantage, and international statecraft, with the most damaging attacks undermining trust and confidence in social, political, and economic institutions.
  • We Have Failed to Impose Costs – The United States has failed to impose sufficient costs on attackers. Norms are more useful in binding friends together than in constraining adversaries. Indictments and sanctions have been ineffective in stopping state-backed hackers.

Why should we care about these findings? Because the Internet today is more fragmented, less free, and more dangerous for all of us. Just like we have to rethink our strategy towards our adversaries like China, we need to change how we think about technology.

Cyber Attacks Twitter Graphic

We should also care because we are already on the trajectory where the next 40 years of innovation will make the last 40 years look like we were just monkeys playing in the dirt with sticks. If, in 2060, we want to be talking about how technological advancement further uplifted humanity rather than constrained it, then we are going to have to change our ways.

To reorient our society to take on this challenge our Task Force came up with the following three primary recommendations:

  • Build a Trusted, Protected Internet Coalition – Digital trade agreements will have a significant influence on the future of the world economy. The United States needs to work with partner countries to build the next generation of digital trade agreements, such as agreeing to and adopting a shared policy on digital privacy that is interoperable with Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
  • Balance Targeted Pressure, Disruptive Cyber Operations, and Pragmatic Norms – While norms are more useful in binding friends together than in constraining adversaries, the U.S. and our allies should be the example of setting norms against destructive attacks on things like election and financial systems. But we must also hold states accountable for malicious activity perpetrated by their citizens, even if the activity originates from outside their borders.
  • Get the U.S.  House in Order – Cyberspace is now indisputably one of the central domains in which the United States competes with its adversaries. Digital competition must be a pillar of the national security strategy. Successful cyber strategy will mirror successful foreign policy, and requires leveraging political, diplomatic, military, and economic measures to achieve aims in cyberspace.

…the next 40 years of innovation will make the last 40 years look like we were just monkeys playing in the dirt with sticks.

These issues should matter to all Americans because since the end of the Second World War, our economy, way of life, and success as a nation have been based on America being the global leader in advanced technology. Maintaining this position is no longer guaranteed.  But together we can resolve the problems which now confront us. Because in our great history this is what Americans have always done.

To read the complete CFR Task force report click here.

First time reading? If you want rational takes on foreign policy, politics and technology then sign up below for “The Brief.” It’s a twice a month email on things that aren’t being discussed but should – all in 5 minutes or less. You can register below.

American Reboot

An Idealist's Guide to Getting Big Things Done

Star Rating Star Rating
4.5 out of 5 Based on 132 reviews

About the book

Will draws on his unique experiences in back alleys of dangerous places, boardrooms of international businesses, and the halls of Congress to lay out a detailed plan to “reboot America,” offering a fresh start to a country mired in political divides and internal strife.

Mike Yantis, Jr.
Star Rating Star Rating
Verified Purchase

Will Hurd tells a great story about his life and his experiences in the CIA, private business, and as a Congressman.

The book also serves as a playbook for like minded Republicans that want to transform the party from the extremes of Trump back to a solutions based party that actually gets things done.

EdFromTexas
Star Rating Star Rating
Verified Purchase

This is one of the best books I have ever read. Part personal story, part political analysis, but mainly just common sense thinking and analysis of solutions to problems.

Will Hurd is an amazing writer and person and I expect to see him do great things in the future.

Kep
Star Rating Star Rating
Verified Purchase

This was a great read. As someone who tends to identify as an Independent or moderate, I thought Mr. Hurd made some great points and offered thoughtful solutions.

I hope he considers a run for political office again, I'd vote for him in a heartbeat.

Brussel
Star Rating Star Rating
Verified Purchase

A life long Republican I had lost hope that I would ever vote Republican again after the extremist views have taken over the party over the last 6 years.

This book covered all my values & concerns in a nuanced way that the majority of politicians today seem incapable of doing.

Hurd has the biography and the charisma and the God-given political chops to put the Republican Party — and the rest of the country — on notice.
The Atlantic
Fox News Logo
The Wall Streel Journal Logo
CNN Logo
CBS News Logo
ABC News Logo
USA Today Logo
Quote Mark
America has become an exceptional nation not because of what we have taken but because of what we have given.

Will Hurd

Will Hurd Image
Play video
June 18, 2023
New Cold War Between U.S. and China Explained
Will's op-ed in the The NH Journal about migration and border control.
Close video popup

About Will

Will Hurd has spent the past 20 years on the front lines of the most pressing fights facing our nation, in the Middle East, Congress, and the highest levels of business and tech.

Will has spent his life fighting for our country, and he will take those decades of experience with him as he fights for all us.

Quote Mark
I dream of an America where we have the smartest kids in the world. Every child in the U.S., regardless of location or age, should have access to a safe, world-class education.

WILL HURD

The choice we face

In every decision we make, we stand at a crossroads. The path of division and quick fixes is well-trodden, but it’s time we consider a different route – one paved with unity and foresight.

Imagine an America where common sense prevails, where policies are crafted with the people’s best interests at heart, and our collective strengths are the foundation of national progress.

This is more than a possibility. It’s a choice we can make right now. By coming together, we have the power to foster a nation that champions innovation, inclusivity, and integrity.

What do we agree on?

91%
Believe it’s important to protect free speech
86%
Believe college education is important for success
79%
Support the development of alternative energy sources
86%
Believe it is essential to maintain Social Security
89%
Support background checks for all gun buyers
71%
Believe that LGBTQ+ individuals should have equal rights
82%
Say it is important for the country to do more regarding race inequality
72%
Are unhappy with the current US economy
70%
Believe the federal government doesn't share enough information
94%
Are concerned about pollution of drinking water
71%
Believe the nation's infrastructure is in need of major repairs
85%
Believe that access to affordable housing is a problem
Politico Magazine

The future of the GOP

Daily Dot

The most interesting man in Congress

Allegheny College

Prize for Civility in Public Life

Chinese

Blocked by the most Chinese Diplomats

Russia

Sanctioned by Vladimir Putin

Hear from People

What’s a modern republican look like?

We’re a nation full of people with these values. If this describes you, you might be a modern Republican.

Respectful and Polite

Strong old school manners. You respect others, and say "please" and "thank you"

Fair

You give someone a fair shot

Empathic

You're ready to put yourself in the shoes of someone else.

Informed

No matter street smarts or book smarts, you understand an education is important

Family Values

You put your family above everything and do everything you can to succeed

Responsible

You take responsibility for your actions and believe in personal responsibility

Kind

You help others and you're always quick to smile

Persevering

You don't let a little hardship get in your way

Compassionate

You know that we're better together and you are ready to help
AI Summary